Tuesday, 26 April 2011

Polish Goverment Protests Against Dutch Anti-Immigration Policy

A political row is brewing between Warsaw and the Hague concerning the possible expulsion of EU migrants from Holland.

Holland is governed by a centre-right minority coalition government that depends upon the support of the far-right Party of Freedom (led by Geert Wilders). This government has followed a trend set in some other European countries of using the politics of Islamophobia and anti-immigrant prejudice to boost its popularity. Recently attention has turned to immigrants from Central-Eastern Europe (CEE) and particularly Poland. There are currently around 200,000 migrants from CEE living in Holland, of which an estimated 115,000 are from Poland.

Wilders has long campaigned against immigration from CEE. The issue is now being taken up by the mainstream parties, with the government announcing that it plans to send home immigrants from other EU states who had been unemployed for more than 3 months. The Polish government has quite rightly pointed out that this violates the EU directive (38/2000), which guarantees the free-movement and residence of EU citizens in other Member States.

The reality of life for most migrants coming from CEE to Holland is one of exploitation. Often they find low-paid insecure work through employment agencies and are housed in packed boarding houses. If they lose their jobs these migrants often end up homeless and therefore potentially reliant upon social benefits. Politicians (including some from the left) have been warning of a 'tsunami' of CEE immigrants overwhelming the Dutch social services. The reality is that only 690 people from CEE are currently drawing social benefits in Holland and just 1,527 unemployment benefits.

With the German and Austrian labour markets set to open up to CEE next month a dangerous precedent is being set in Holland. This restricts one of the most fundamental rights of the free movement of people within the EU. Coming on the back of the French decision to expel Roma immigrants from Romania out of France, it is important that this move by the Dutch government is opposed and that the principle of the free movement of labour within the EU is upheld.

Below I publish a recent article from the Financial Times on this issue:

Poles at sharp end of Dutch politics: Lukasz and Alicja left their native Poland for the Netherlands 10 months ago, expecting to find an open and tolerant society befitting their hosts’ reputation. They were disappointed.

Like most of the estimated 150,000 Polish migrants here, the couple found work through employment agencies, which put them in the tight-packed boarding houses known as “Polish hotels”. Alicja, 24, picked flowers while Lukasz, 26, who has a university degree in logistics, started picking tomatoes then moved on to repairing trucks.

After taxes, social insurance and rent, they were left with about €200 ($290) each per week. Salaries like these have attracted tens of thousands of young Poles such as Lukasz and Alicja since 2007, when the Netherlands opened its labour market to them.

East European migrants now provide most of the labour force for the Netherlands’ greenhouse-based agricultural industry. The Dutch experience is being watched by Germany and Austria, which open their borders to east European workers on May 1.

Unemployment in the Netherlands stands at 4.3 per cent, well below the European Union average of 9.5 per cent. But with the electoral trend to the right, politicians have begun attacking immigration from eastern Europe.

In provincial elections last month, Geert Wilders, the far-right anti-Islamic politician, accused Polish workers of crime, drunkenness and taking Dutch jobs. Even politicians from the Labour and Socialist parties have warned of a “tsunami” of east Europeans overwhelming Dutch social services.

Now Lukasz and Alicja fear that, like the Turkish and Moroccan migrants who came here in the 1970s and 1980s, the Poles have fallen victim to the Netherlands’ love-hate relationship with immigrants.

“They decided to open the borders themselves, and now they want us to go home,” says Lukasz. “It’s absurd.”

Until recently campaigns against east European immigrants were the exclusive province of Mr Wilders and his Party for Freedom (PVV). Since elections last year made the PVV the third-largest party, mainstream parties have taken up the issue. Earlier this month the rhetoric became government policy, when Henk Kamp, minister of social affairs from the governing Liberal party, announced plans to send back home east Europeans who had been unemployed for more than three months.

Mr Kamp’s plans have turned a domestic political issue into a European controversy.

The Polish government says deporting its citizens for economic reasons would violate EU rules on labour migration. Viviane Reding, European Commission vice-president, has warned that the Commission will “loudly and clearly” oppose Dutch rules that do not meet EU standards. Dutch officials admit their proposal to require five years’ residency before claiming unemployment benefits violates EU agreements.

Meanwhile, Polish officials point out that, like Lukasz and Alicja, most Polish migrants pay Dutch taxes and social insurance premiums. “We are talking about people who are entitled under Dutch law to receive such assistance,” says Janusz Wolosz, spokesman for the Polish embassy in The Hague.

Louis Bontes, a former policeman turned PVV member of parliament, cites complaints of public drunkenness and noise, and opposition to Poles claiming unemployment or other social benefits. “I get e-mails from citizens who say the problems keep getting worse,” he says. However, much of the antipathy to Polish immigrants reflects Dutch fear of ethnic and cultural change. Complaints that Polish migrants degrade neighbourhoods often refer not so much to their behaviour as to the fact that they are there.

“People can’t identify any more with the place where they live,” says Mr Bontes. “You can see why someone who lives in one of these streets in Rotterdam where only 20-30 per cent of the people are native Rotterdammers just doesn’t feel comfortable there anymore, period.”

Civic groups that provide services for Polish migrants agree a minority can create social burdens. Poles have become the “dominant group” at some homeless shelters, says Ernst-Jan Stroes, director of Den Haag East Europe Foundation.

But the groups say the employment agencies are partly to blame. The agencies often house their workers four or more to a room in squalid converted family housing, while others are housed in trailer parks, also isolated from Dutch society. “The employment agencies abuse them, the slum landlords rip them off and in the end they wind up out on the street,” says Mr Stroes.

After seven years in the Netherlands, Krystyna Cichon speaks fluent Dutch and works for a local water utility. “I can tell you stories about employment agencies you wouldn’t believe,” she says, recalling the problems she faced when she first arrived.

An agency brought her from Poland in 2004 with a promise of work folding clothes for a fashion label, Ms Cichon says. Instead, she and six other women were deposited at a meat factory and ordered to pack chicken parts on an assembly line. She says such deception is routine at the less reputable agencies.

Janusz and Alicja have now saved up enough to rent a small apartment. But, like most Poles working here, they still have virtually no contact with local people apart from supervisors at work.

“The Dutch think they are very open,” says Ms Cichon. “But they’re not.” Janusz and Alicja’s names have been changed to preserve their anonymity


  1. If some countries insist on having large families and being backward, they have no right to dump their citizens onto more progressive, responsible countries.

  2. The ignorance of racists knows no limits. And although it has no bearing on this issue, you may like to know that Poles have one of the lowest birth rates in Europe

  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.


Go for it - but if its abusive then it gets blocked